Poor Man's Ribeye with Steak Beautiful
Ph.B.

Poor Man's Ribeye with Steak Beautiful

Chuckeye steaks — ribeye marbling at half the price

Prep15 minutes
Cook Time45 minutes
Servings2 people
Difficultymedium
Recommended WoodHickory or oak (225–250°F indirect)
Pairs WithSpice Beautiful — Hickory
Original archive photo for Poor Man's Ribeye with Steak Beautiful
Original photo from the Jim Quessenberry archives

Instructions

Let the steaks rest to room temp if they've been refrigerated. Lightly drizzle and rub the steaks on both sides with a thin layer of olive oil while gently massaging the Hickory Rub into the meat.

Warm up your smoker/grill with indirect/offset fire. Get the fire up to a point where you'd normally smoke meats but not too hot — aim for 225°F to 250°F. Place the meat on the surface and slow smoke until the internal temp reaches 125°F.

While the steaks smoke, smash and chop the garlic clove. Mix it into 1/4 stick of room-temperature butter until you have a consistent garlic compound butter ready for plating.

Once the steaks hit 125°F internal, remove them and let them rest. Stoke the fire (or heat a cast-iron pan) to at least 375°F for searing.

Sear the steaks for no more than 2 minutes per side. Plate with a dollop of compound garlic butter and serve with your choice of salad, potato, or steamed veggies.

Pairs with Spice Beautiful — Hickory

From the Legacy

The chuckeye is the end piece left when ribeyes are cut — same marbling, half the price per pound at the butcher. Smoke low, sear hot, finish with compound garlic butter.

The full story

Quess — The Arkansas Trav'ler

Michael Quessenberry's memoir of Jim's championship journey — from Birdeye pits to two-time World Champion. Pre-order now.

Pre-Order the Book
Share this recipe
X Facebook